2005 Toyota Tacoma trans slipp

Cameron Technician Ontario Posted   Latest   Edited  
Unsolved
Drivetrain
2005 Toyota Tacoma 4.0L (1GR-FE) 5-spd (A750E)
Periodic Transmission Slip

Hi folks

This truck has ~275000km on the clock and is brand new to me. It was towed to me in for replacement of transmission cooler rigid lines as they were leaking. I replaced the lines, emptied the trans pan and refilled with WS fluid utilizing the temperature slow dribble method as per OEM. I got a call from the owner today saying that periodically the trans will slip when driving., This symptom was apparent before the replacement of the lines as well. 

I'm not a huge fan of adding any “miracle in a bottle” fluids but the owner is looking for inexpensive options. I'm confident that the fluid is at the right level but with a drain/refill only 2-3 litres was used so this could also be old fluid.

Any suggestions?

0
Jared Diagnostician
Maryland
Jared
 

Before you do anything else, unplug the transmission connector on driver's side and inspect for corroded pins. Notorious… and I mean notorious for corrosion.

+1
Ð Awarded
Erik Diagnostician
Florida
Erik
 

They are also notorious for torque shudder as well. As least the handful Ive seen down this way in Florida. Not saying having ever done this but Ford FRiction modifier works great in most trans applications unless there is a software update to change the shift points but by that time its too late and replacement of converter or trans is a sure thing. Make sure your SLU pid isnt tweaking hard…

+2
Ð Awarded
Funny
Interesting
Jon Owner/Technician
California
Jon
 

AFTER - eliminating everything else… if you're sure that you have a clutch pack that is starting to slip, you can try draining 2 quarts of the WS and adding back in 2 quarts of Type F transmission fluid. Type F contains no friction modifiers and will let the clutches grab harder with less slippage. Clear the memory and shift points etc. Start with 2 quarts and release it to the customer. If…

0
Ð Awarded
Helpful
Agree
Disagree
Unprofessional
Jared Diagnostician
Maryland
Jared
 

My personal experience is that only WS works. We have even had problems with good branded “universal” types that said they were WS compliant. You need the right friction modifiers for the partial TCC modes (when it shudders due to fluid degradation). If fluid renewal does not cure shudders at those times, it is torque converter time. Maybe Honda DW-1 would be okay, but at that rate, might as…

0
Ð Awarded
Cameron Technician
Ontario
Cameron
 

thanks fellas for this. I had not inspected the connector so I'll hope that maybe that's the culprit. As far as I know, this truck has only had WS put into it (which is also what I used). I do wonder about torque shudder as the main problem. I'll get the truck back and see.

0
Ð Awarded
Cmore Mechanic
Connecticut
Cmore
 

Jon, why not just add a bottle of Lubegard friction modifier or shudder fix? I've had good luck with their products plus it's a lot easier to do.

+1
Ð Awarded
Agree
Jon Owner/Technician
California
Jon
 

Hey Cmore - I think the complaint is for a slip as I understand it?? Not a shudder? I think the Lubegard adds more friction modifiers? The Type F fluid doesn't contain any modifiers so it combats slippage but can cause harsh shifts if its not used correctly. My suggestion is only for an aging transmission that has minor slippage. We were actually taught this at the factory Toyota school in…

+2
Ð Awarded
Agree
Cmore Mechanic
Connecticut
Cmore
 

Interesting. I always thought Type-F was a high friction fluid. We used to use it in GMs to get a firmer shift. Thought the friction helped “bite” the clutches instead of slipping. As far as downvoting, wasn't me. I looked up a few different brands of type-f, Mobil says “used in transmissions designed for a high-friction fluid”, Motorcraft says “It's a high-static friction fluid”. Am I…

0
Ð Awarded
David Owner/Technician
Alberta
David
 

Type F, which is pretty obsolete now, was just a bit thicker when cold as compared to the early Dexron. Once it is warm, same results as Dexron. We used Dexron II in all of them back in the early 70's with no issues we ever saw or heard of. Those transmissions pretty much all used the same friction materials and steel clutches. Pumps were all internal gear (crescent type). Using Type F would…

0
Ð Awarded
Eric Owner/Technician
Wisconsin
Eric
 

They were the older GM 3 speed transmissions that would get a soft/slipping 1-2 shift. Adding 5 or 6 quarts of type F would firm up the 1-2 shift and a careful driver could get a year or two more driving out of it. If you drove it too long with the slipping 1-2 shift and let it turn into a big shift flare instead of a slip then the type F fluid wouldn't help.

0
Ð Awarded
Jon Owner/Technician
California
Jon
 

You are correct - it lacks the modifiers that cause the clutch packs to slip. The Type F will make the clutch packs grab sooner and firmer. The other fluids have friction modifiers that cause the clutch pack to slip a little (by design) to avoid harsh shifts.

0
Ð Awarded
David Owner/Technician
Alberta
David
 

The shift overlap (smooth shifts=slipping) in those old technology transmissions forced slip to occur on the clutch packs, The friction materials were much different then. The early Fords (up to around 1965) used bronze against steel which was a far different friction coefficient than the materials used today. The shift times were also much slower overall for most of them. Those units were not…

0
Ð Awarded
Jon Owner/Technician
California
Jon
 

This was actually taught in Toyota MDT school in Irvine - for anyone that downvoted it - just FYI

0
Ð Awarded
Eric Owner/Technician
Wisconsin
Eric
 

I used to use that good old type F years ago to help a slipping GM transmission, you could get a year or two more use out of those old cars unless you were hard on it.

+1
Ð Awarded
Thanks
Jon Owner/Technician
California
Jon
 

I guess its just us old guys… that post was down voted a few times - if you understand transmission operation then you get it…

0
Ð Awarded
Eric Owner/Technician
Wisconsin
Eric
 

Most people think of transmissions like they think of a computer, a magic object that is impossible to understand. I mean really, what can a sun and planets have to do with a computer? How can a sprag clutch work in a transmission, it only turns freely in one direction and locks up in the other direction, how can you get reverse with a sprag clutch?

0
Ð Awarded
David Owner/Technician
Alberta
David
 

Eric, you reminded me of my complaint when people say “internal problem” when talking of transmissions. You are correct, they are not impossible or magic. One of my friends used to call them “AutoMagic transmissions” LOL Internal problem does say they may not have a good idea about what is failed or failing. Hence how would they really know if some additive would make the difference? We would…

0
Ð Awarded
Eric Owner/Technician
Wisconsin
Eric
 

Don't get me started about Honda (and some Ford) transmissions that are supposed to be of the “Automatic” variety. I learned on the good old transmission from the 60's, 70's and 80's. I've kept up to date on most of the newer, at least up to 2015, transmissions. Now they just tax my brain, at least the basics are still the same!

0
Ð Awarded
Jon Owner/Technician
California
Jon
 

Probably one of the greatest inventions was the planetary gear set.

0
Ð Awarded
Marlin Technician
Oregon
Marlin
 

Did you open the thermostat before you did the final level check? If not, it is underfilled. Likely this not the cause of slippage, but it should be correct.

0
Ð Awarded
David Owner/Technician
Alberta
David
 

I doubt the fluid type is the problem for a slip condition. More likely there is some old age made worse with leaking lines and low fluid conditions. The suggestion Marlin makes of rechecking the fluid level is also a very good one. Don't give Mr. Customer too much hope.

+1
Ð Awarded
Agree
Brian Technician
New Jersey
Brian
 

I don’t know what you mean by a slow dribble but any slow dribble out of the over flow to me is under filled. I check them around 113 degrees Fahrenheit at the trans temp sensor and I look for a constant flow about the thickness of a pencil. I think you need atleast another quart if not 2 and then drive it. I have fixed many so called shudders bunch adding the correct amount of fluid and ones I…

0
Ð Awarded
Cameron Technician
Ontario
Cameron
 

Thanks Brian.. dribble is probably not the right word - stream would be better. I'm getting this truck back on Saturday and will reconfirm proper fluid level. I appreciate your help!

0
Ð Awarded
Brian Technician
New Jersey
Brian
 

Good luck. If they still had dipsticks - things would be so much simpler.

+1
Ð Awarded
Agree